Tournament Report - Richmond Comix, 10/28/01

Beyond Dominia: The Type One Magic Mill: Tournament Archive -- ALL TOURNAMENT REPORT THREADS GO HERE: Tournament Report - Richmond Comix, 10/28/01

-->
By Katzby (Katzby) on Sunday, October 28, 2001 - 12:14 pm:

My name is Abe Corson and I am a junior at Virginia Tech. I am one of the three “VT Dudes” in attendance at Richmond yesterday as previously reported upon by URMage. Anyway, here’s what happened.

One week ago –

Perusing the T1 mill, I read about the tournament. I’d yet to play my keeper deck in any sanctioned event and I thought that this would be a good opportunity. I read that Matt and Darren planned to attend which made me want to go even more. Unfortunately, the tournament site was roughly a 4-hour drive away and I have no car.

I ask my trusty sidekick Egon if he had any interest in going (driving me) but he complains that he had no type 1 deck and wouldn’t want to play without one. This is problematic in that the cards I have with me at school are my keeper deck, its sideboard components, and the pieces to put together some similar decks. I could almost build him mono blue, but I don’t have extra drains and fows. I could almost build him academy, but I don’t have an extra stroke or undergrounds. My other cards are at home, which is an even longer drive away than the tournament, and I don’t particularly trust dad to find and mail the correct cards to me.

I email my other friend Jordan to see if he wants to go (drive me). He asks me for some more information and I give him the url to Richmond Comix and show him a map I made on mapquest, and he decides to go. Joy! On a side note, Mapquest seems to believe the drive will take just over 4 hours. If I were to ever write an Internet mapping alogirthm, any trip that starts in a college town would calculate both a regular trip time and a male student’s trip time. The latter would be roughly half that of the former.

Thursday –

Jordan messages me and asks if I want to come over for some play testing. Since I’ve played exclusive apprentice for the last 9 months I suppose that I really should get some practice and make sure that I still remember which end of a magic card is up. He picks me up and we go play on his dirty dining room table.

Jordan has two decks, parfait and nether void. His parfait is missing Lotus, Pearl, 4 Abeyance, Balance, and a Serra’s Sanctum. Void is missing just the Jet and Lotus. We play a few games of Keeper v. Parfait, most of which I win. He puts his Void deck together and we play some more games, most of which he wins. He doesn’t yet know which deck he would rather play, so I suggest that he bring both with him and decide there. We make plans to leave on Saturday at 6 amish.

When I get back to the dorms, I mention to Egon that Jordan will have an extra deck that he could use. So Egon is officially in.

Friday –

Completely unrelated. I go to Wal-Mart and buy Silent Hill 2. I was AMAZED with the first one, and I maintain that it is the scariest thing, be it movie, novel, amusement park ride, etc, known to human kind. Sitting in a movie theater or reading a book doesn’t have the same effect on you as a video game. With a video game, you tend to feel as though you ARE the main character. Therefore, instances of the main character in horrific situations within the video game evoke the same feeling as being in one in real life.

I’m about an hour into the second one now, and it looks like it is going to be about as good as the original. The graphics of this thing are insane, as is the voice acting. It looks like, plays out like and feels like a movie (a really spooky and disturbing one). I highly recommend this game and the original to anyone with a psx/psx2.

Saturday –

I wake up at about 5 am to get a shower and some food and stuff. 6 am comes and goes, and Jordan does not appear at my door as promised. 6:45 comes with him finally showing up. We’re off.

We do roughly warp speed up 81 and seem to be making good time. We have some interesting conversation about what happened to the northern VA magic scene in the last couple of years. As far as we can tell, most of the great players in the area (Gallitz, Long, etc) have moved on, moved away, or quit magic. We stop for taco bell for a half an hour or so, then gun it to Richmond. We make it there just as registration begins.

On the way in, we see Matt and Darren playing. Wow neato! Matt’s deck is so cool! As far as I can tell, it’s completely black-bordered. We register, but there is a small matter with regard to Egon’s deck in that we don’t have one for him. Jordan has decided to play Nether Void, which would leave Egon with parfait. Unfortunately, Parfait is missing a good 15 cards at this point (including the wastelands in void and some extra plains) and the entire sideboard. Hm. Jordan and I go through our things and he suggests that we have enough stuff to build him BBS. Jordan has most of the deck including the fows, drains, and morphlings and such. I fill in the components that he does not have (mainly the islands and kegs). I lend my spare Mox Jet to Jordan, my spare Emerald, Ruby, Walk, and Library to Egon, and we basically have his deck. The only glaringly obvious things that are missing are Fact or Fictions (which Jordan buys for $3 each- ow) and a Sol Ring (which we never do anything about). We also manage to put together a decent sideboard for him. We give the deck to Egon and he seems happy with it. I really wasn’t a bad deck for being made exactly 5 minutes before the tournament began.

Round 1 begins… and I get the one bye. Damnit. I could have sword that the organizer and storeowner, Mr. Frank Miller, said that a bye is only worth 2 tournament points, whereas a win is 3, and a draw is 1. I watch Egon crush a surprisingly represented Stasis deck as Jordan gets run over by a Sligh deck played by Ian Dennette. And Jordan wasn’t even playing with Negators (used pump knights instead). Hm, oh well. I wander over at some point to watch the Virginia Tech game and talk to Frank. He’s a really cool shop owner, especially as compared to what I’m used to at home. One game takes almost the entire 65 minutes allotted for the round and I’m growing increasingly more desperate to play.

Finally, it’s time for round two. I get my slip and notice that I have to play… Egon. Ugh. The good news is that I know exactly what is in his deck. The bad news is that I know that he has 4 main deck back to basics. Ok, just focus here.

Game 1: I win the die roll and start with Underground Sea and Lotus. He plays an Island and is done. I attempt to Ancestral at the end of turn, to which Egon has no response. I draw Mind Twist, Force of Will (have 2 other blue cards in hand) and a Sol ring. I untap and play pearl, tap it for Sol Ring, Tundra, tap out and blow off Lotus for black to Mind twist for 5. Egon pitches a Fact or Fiction to force. So, I pitch a Fact or Fiction to force, and Egon loses his remaining 5 cards. Hehe. I draw a FoF next turn and use it, then get a Morphling in short order and end the game.

Sideboard: out- plow, abyss, counterspell, stroke, shaman, zuran orb, in- 4 red blast, 2 aura fracture

Game 2: I believe he started with Library, which I am able to Waste away. I have nothing much to do for the first few turns, and when Egon gets to 4 mana the FoF’s start and they do not let up. He gets a Morphling and I have no red mana to blast, so I die dead.

Game 3: I start with Volcanic, Sol Ring. He just goes island. I play tundra, aura fracture, but I don’t think quite realized what that card does. A turn or two later he tries to Back to Basics, but I demonstrate exactly what aura fracture does by sacrificing a Wasteland to kill it. I get a Morphling and start attacking. He’s at 15 life and plays his own Morphling. I Mana Drain and he has no Force. At 10 life, he tries the next Morphling, and I tap 5 to Force, again, he has no force. At 5 life, he tries Morphling #3. I use the last Counterspell in my hand (a red blast) on it, and he still has no Force. Phew.

I notice that my slip says I have 3 points instead of 2 for the bye. The following round, I see that the next person who got the bye also got 3 points. I am kind of surprised, but I obviously decide not to complain.

Round 3 begins and I am paired against Ian Denette who played the sligh deck that beat Jordan. I’m really confident in my ability to beat sligh, and I have a lot of sideboard cards for the matchup, so I’m not too scared.

Game 1: He starts fast with a couple of early pups and cadets. I can’t get any black mana and die with an Abyss, Demonic Tutor and Mind Twist in hand. Frown.

Sideboard: out- mind twist, counterspell, abyss, stroke, shaman, dismantling blow in- 3 hydroblast, 2 cop: red, 1 ivory mask

I make these changes with the following things in mind. Moat doesn’t deal with his Shamans and this is important in that Shamans like to kill my Zuran Orb. Abyss doesn’t deal with his Ball Lightnings and also doesn’t deal with Shaman very well. I assumed that he would be sideboarding out most of his creatures anyway in favor of the scroll and burn route to victory because keeper is somewhat known for being able to deal with creatures. As a consequence, I decided to play with neither Moat nor Abyss and instead focus upon playing cop: red and ivory mask as quickly as possible. I removed the Blow because I feel that the only thing worth blowing is a scroll, but mask is just a better card at dealing with scrolls. I took out the shaman because, like the blow, it is not a permanent solution to cursed scroll in the sense that it can very easily be burnt away, and I’d have to invest too many counterspells in protecting it.

Game 2: All goes well and I get an early cop: red and eventually tutor for my mask. I notice a very weak creature start from him. It was like first turn fanatic, third turn pup. The turn after I play cop: red, he price of progresses. I shrug and tap 1 to prevent it. He concedes.

Game 3: I drew 4 land, zuran orb, a fact or fiction and a hydroblast. He starts with a first turn Shaman which I consider blasting but instead decide to save it and hold on to the orb. I drew 3 lands over my next 3 turns and am somewhat annoyed. He bolted me at some point and attacked with the shaman to put me at 14. At the end of his 4th turn, I tap 2 tundra, a volcanic and an underground to Fact or Fiction. He responds with Price of Progress and Fork. If I had a single force in my hand, I could counter both of them, but unfortunately, I do not. I lose what should be an easy matchup.

I turn around and watch Egon finish his game at the table behind me. As it turns out, he’s playing Darren, and I begin watching just in time to see both of them make incredibly bad mistakes. Egon has a morphling, 4 islands, and a tapped Grim Monlith in play. Darren has a red blast and mana drain in hand, a city of brass, and two untapped source of blue, and apparently no way to deal with the morphling. Darren is done, and egon taps out to untap his monolith (!). And Darren does nothing (!!!). Egon untaps and wins the game with that Morphling. In Darren’s defense, he told me after the game that he had slept only 3 hours the previous night and his brain wasn’t working. In Egon’s defense, Egon is a moron. Er, no wait. In Egon’s defense, he was playing a deck that he had never even seen before, and was doing well with it.

Round 4 begins and I am playing against David Williams. He’s a really nice guy playing suicide black. My sideboard doesn’t really contain a whole lot of helpful tools aside from the Moat, so I’m somewhat concerned about this game.

Game 1: He wins the die roll and starts with swamp, carnophage. Incidentally, this will be the only game all day I have against him in which he does not start with dark ritual. Nothing terribly interesting happens. He has a skittering skirge, a carnophage and he tries to cast a phyrexian scuta. I inform him that as soon as he announces the scuta, he has to sacrifice the skirge. He does so, then I counter the scuta. At some point I tutor for an Abyss and play it. The next turn I get a morphling and he concedes.

Sideboard: out- gorilla shaman in- moat

Game 2: I have no idea what he sideboarded in against me. He starts with something insane like first turn Ritual, Duress (taking one of my 3 force of wills), Ritual, Hymn (I force pitching the other force), Carnophage and Sarcomancy. Guh. What a bad card force of will is. Anyway, I have not a whole lot to do for the first few turns, and eventually he casts a specter. By turn 4 I have Sol Ring, Zuran Orb, Mox Pearl, Black Lotus, Tundra and Underground Sea in Play, and I’m at 2 life or so. I have nothing in my hand and I hope to draw Balance but instead get the Dismantling Blow (I really wish I had more sideboard cards for suicide black). I think for a minute and attempt something tricky. I blow off the Lotus for Blue, Tap the Tundra for white, the Sea for Black, tap the Sol Ring, eat both of my lands and Dismantling Blow my Zuran Orb with kicker. This would leave me with 0 lands, 0 creatures, and enough mana to cast Balance should I draw it. I did not draw it. But still, David mentions that he liked what I was doing and he compliments me for being so tricky.

Game 3: My first 7 cards have 0 mana sources. My next 6 cards have 0 mana sources. My next 5 cards have 0 mana sources. I want to cry, but I keep. I tell him to go ahead but he is confused because he thought that I was playing first. I told him that I am, and he understands. He proceeds to Ritual out 3 first turn carnophages and casts #4 on turn 2. Well, he wins, and I’m positive 2-2-0 is not enough to make it to the top 8 (there were 17 people).

As it turns out, Jordan and Egon had to play each other but drew instead. I desideboard and put my cards away. Frank announces the top 8 pairings and… I’m in?? I’m truly surprised but I am glad to still be in. I am matched against the top seed, Ian Denette (again).

Game 1: We talk a little bit before the game and he mentions that he thinks our match up comes down to the die roll. I personally don’t agree with that in that I feel keeper should beat sligh regardless of who goes first, but proceed to win the die roll anyway. I start with a first turn mox and ancestral. The game goes long with an Abyss in play and scroll on his side. I have a zuran orb in play, and I keep drawing lands. This is ok, because each land I draw brings me closer to something more game-ending. I have an active library in play and I am drawing and FoFing like a mad man. I stroke for 7 at some point. Eventually, I cast a very broken will for Ancestral, Walk, the Lotus, Tutor for another counterspell and Morphling. He dies a few turns later.

Sideboard: out- mind twist, counterspell, stroke, shaman, misdirection, dismantling blow in- 3 hydroblast, 2 cop: red, 1 ivory mask

I use the same philosophy as before except that this time I decide to keep the Abyss in. I get an early cop: red but he has scroll. Eventually, I draw demonic tutor and go get my Mask. I am able to prevent basically everything he does, but I cannot draw a morphling and am getting frustrated. The game goes on for a good 30 turns and I am sure he is saving up a hand full of 7 red blasts and anarchy. I continue to not draw morphling and hover at 2 life or so. Eventually, he tries to anarchy. I drain, he pyros, I drain that, he pyros that. I have several more counterspells in hand, but I FoF in response in hope that I can dig into a morphling. FoF reveals nothing helpful, but I take a pile with a timewalk in it. I then hydroblast his pyroblast.

I untap, take my turn, timewalk and say I’m done with that turn. He says:”Don’t you mana burn for 5?”

D’oh.

I say, “ok, I’ll just sacrifice some lands then” hoping that he’ll let me do it. He does not let me do it, and that’s game. Tough way to lose a game, but it was certainly my fault.

Game 3:

I get a second turn cop: red and I think he stalls at a couple of mountains. He gets a scroll and I play The Abyss. I vampiric tutor down to 2 to go get my mask and play it. I prevent most of the damage and finally get a Morphling into play. He does try to anarchy at some point, but I counter. I remember to use the Morphling’s ability during my upkeep each time to prevent him from falling in the hole, and he concedes after I attack 3 times.

Jordan and Egon both lost their games so I’m the only one left in the top 4. I am paired against David Williams (again).

Game 1: He does first turn double ritual (jesus!) duress, hymn and hypnotic specter. I can’t draw anything to save me in the next few turns, and I think he played a necropotence. He kills me very dead.

Game 2: He rituals a first turn specter, but I force. I am slowly getting control of the game, but I can’t draw the abyss that I really want. At some point, I am at 6 life, with him at 7. He has a phyrexian scuta (kicked) and a mishra’s factory in play and attacks with both. I do not have enough lands untapped to block/kill the scuta and save the morphling. I think for a minute or two and decide to block the scuta and pump its toughness without getting either killed. I hope to draw a wasteland or strip mine on the following turn to deal with the factory and have enough mana to attack for 5 and block the scuta. He has no combat tricks, so I go to 4. Then he plays a carnophage, which is bad for me because I can’t block enough next turn to save myself. I untap and draw Fact or Fiction. I count my mana and see that I have a sol ring, 5 untapped lands (one city), and two moxes. I tap 4 to FoF, but it only reveals a land, a stroke of genius, another FoF, and a lotus. David thinks for a minute or two and puts the Lotus and FoF in one pile and the other cards in the other pile. I tap 4 more (leaving just the city untapped) to FoF again. This time, it turns over another fof, 2 lands, mystical tutor and regrowth. He asks to see my graveyard and I hand it over. He puts the regrowth in one pile and the other 4 in the other pile. I also look at my graveyard and see a demonic tutor near the bottom. I think for a moment, then play the Lotus, tap the City for green (down to 1) blow off the lotus for black, and play regrowth. He asks me what I’m targeting, and I say that regrowth doesn’t target. I pick up my demonic tutor and cast it. There are like 10 cards left in my library, and one of them is my Zuran Orb. I put it directly into play and tell him that I’m done. I win the damage race and we move to the next game.

Game 3: He has first turn double ritual AGAIN with I think duress, hymn, 2 carnophage. I simply cannot deal with this and die fast. David was a cool guy and I didn’t mind losing to him one bit.

And that was it for me. I got a couple invasion packs and a few odyssey packs for making it to the top 4. That’s a refund of the tournament fee (although not the gas money), so I was happy to accept them. We stayed and watched the finals in which Josh beat David with OSE, then got out of there.

I want to say that this was an excellent tournament. It was run very well, the organizer was a great guy, the prize was generous and the entry fee was reasonable. Also, the decks represented consisted of what I believe to be an accurate illustration of type 1’s diversity. I got to meet (or look at) Darren and Matt, which was my primary motivation, and I had a good time.

And, oh yeah, my deck list:

4 Tundra
4 Underground Sea
3 Volcanic Island
4 City of Brass
3 Wasteland
1 Strip Mine
1 Academy
1 Library
5 Mox
1 Lotus
1 Sol Ring
4 Drain
4 FoW
1 Counterspell
1 Misdirection
2 Morphling
4 Fact or Fiction
1 Stroke of Genius
1 Ancestral
1 Walk
1 Mystical Tutor
1 Demonic Tutor
1 Vampiric Tutor
1 Twist
1 Will
1 Abyss
1 Plow
1 Balance
1 Edict
1 Zuran Orb
1 Regrowth
1 Gorilla Shaman
1 Dismantling Blow

Sideboard:
3 Hydroblast
2 Cop: Red
1 Ivory Mask
1 Moat
1 Jester’s Cap
4 REB
2 Aura Fracture
1 Tormod’s Crypt


Katzby


By Sssmwc (Sssmwc) on Sunday, October 28, 2001 - 12:35 pm:

With the influx of new players from VaTech (sorry about the loss to Syr yesterday) and w/ Matt's visit from NY the Richmond metagame took a turn towards control. The night before Brownstone was doing great against Keeper played by Matt. Saturday it was less than great. The field looked roughly like this:
2 OSE
2 Keeper
1 BBS
1 Brownstone
1 Suicide Black
1 WWu
1 Az Sligh
3 SRB
1 R/U mana denial (as rouge as you get)
1 Stasis

I didn't see the other decks in attendence but with a 17 person turn out w/ some regulars not in attendence (ie Jay) the T1 scene is building up.

It would be great to see the VaTech guys come back down for the future tournies since it really fleshes out the metagame. I'll post the most recent brownstone decklist soon..hopefully some can help shed some light on how it can alter it so I can be more consistent vs. control.


By Barktooth Warbeard (Barktooth) on Sunday, October 28, 2001 - 12:52 pm:

Nice report!

Cheers, Barktooth


By Elrond, the High Priest & Pokemon Slayer (Elrond) on Sunday, October 28, 2001 - 01:33 pm:


Quote:

If I were to ever write an Internet mapping alogirthm, any trip that starts in a college town would calculate both a regular trip time and a male student’s trip time. The latter would be roughly half that of the former.




ROFL. You're right about on with this one.


By Azhrei (Azhrei) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 12:19 am:

"I got to meet (or look at) Darren and Matt, which was my primary motivation, and I had a good time."

Come back, by all means. I'll miss the next two since I'll be home on breaks, but in January I will be a recurring mainstay yet again. I'd have been more personable, but I was exhausted (for the local players reference, was coming home from Josh's at night and suddenly couldn't remember where the hell I was or where I was going) and was trying to concentrate as best I could on the tournament. I hope you guys make the trip back though, as it was good to have more and new people.


By Stephen Michael Menendian (Smmenen) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 09:22 am:

"Game 2: I have no idea what he sideboarded in against me. He starts with something insane like first turn Ritual, Duress (taking one of my 3 force of wills), Ritual, Hymn (I force pitching the other force), Carnophage and Sarcomancy. Guh. What a bad card force of will is. Anyway, I have not a whole lot to do for the first few turns, and eventually he casts a specter. By turn 4 I have Sol Ring, Zuran Orb, Mox Pearl, Black Lotus, Tundra and Underground Sea in Play, and I’m at 2 life or so. I have nothing in my hand and I hope to draw Balance but instead get the Dismantling Blow (I really wish I had more sideboard cards for suicide black). I think for a minute and attempt something tricky. I blow off the Lotus for Blue, Tap the Tundra for white, the Sea for Black, tap the Sol Ring, eat both of my lands and Dismantling Blow my Zuran Orb with kicker. This would leave me with 0 lands, 0 creatures, and enough mana to cast Balance should I draw it. I did not draw it. But still, David mentions that he liked what I was doing and he compliments me for being so tricky. "

Do you realize that you could have blew up the Sarcomancy enchantment instead of the Zuran Orb. Then you could have hoped to draw another land and stayed alive.

Stephen Menendian


By Forever Escapist on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 08:00 pm:

The storeowner, Frank Miller.
Is he the Author//Artist Frank Miller?
Creator of Sin City?

Maybe it is just some coincidence.


By Stephen Michael Menendian (Smmenen) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 08:37 pm:

I was wondering that too, but think about it: how the hell would Frank Miller have time to manage a store? There is no way.

Stephen Menendian


By Azhrei (Azhrei) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 08:53 pm:

You guys are freaking kidding me, right?


By Stephen Michael Menendian (Smmenen) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 09:00 pm:

Yes we're kidding you. But, hmmm, oh yeah, you play MAGIC! the collectible card game. You have no room to talk Azhrei.

Would some one please respond to my comment about the play error.

Stephen Menendian


By Azhrei (Azhrei) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 10:14 pm:

I have no room to talk about what?


By Rakso, Patriarch & Rules Ayatollah (Rakso) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 10:27 pm:

What more do you want us to say about the play?


By Stephen Michael Menendian (Smmenen) on Monday, October 29, 2001 - 10:36 pm:

Oh puhlease Azhrei.

Stephen Menendin

P.S. Ten bucks says you'll consider saying "puhlease what?" next.


By anonymous on Wednesday, October 31, 2001 - 12:45 pm:

Side note: Regrowth does Target a card in the graveyard and you have to show it to your opponent if they want to see it.


Add a Message


This is a private posting area. A valid username and password combination is required to post messages to this discussion.
Username:  
Password: